Victor Sinclair D'artagnan Panetela Maduro Tube

Stay away

Nov 27, 2024

Would give zero if I could. About 40% came broken and unsmokable. The ones I could smoke were terrible. Absolute bust. Do not purchase.

Robbie D.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Too skinny and too long

Oct 11, 2023

Too skinny and too long compared to my favorite cigar. The flavor was okay. I would buy them again though.

Vickie R.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Terrible smoke

Apr 18, 2023

They were dry. They kept going out. Terrible draw. What a disappointment.

Dan C.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

I like the sweet flavor

Jan 26, 2023

I like the sweet flavor with the rich smoke. A good draw too.

Mark W.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Enjoyed size and tasi

Nov 25, 2022

Enjoyed size and tasi

russell o.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

These are decent cigars, smooth,

Oct 15, 2022

These are decent cigars, smooth, good flavor but small in diameter. Some in the shipment were very dry to the point of being crumbly. I prefer a slightly larger diameter cigar (30 to 34) so I probably will not be ordering these again.

Thomas B.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Great Thin Cigars

Apr 15, 2022

Great thin cigars!

Mark L.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

great draw like the length

Apr 07, 2022

great draw like the length its a great twenty minute break sitting outside with a tumbler of brandy or jameson

joan s.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

bought 2 boxes of these.

Feb 09, 2022

bought 2 boxes of these. in one box each cigar was so loosely rolled they would not stay lit. the second box was better... only 1/3 were poorly rolled.

stephen k.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Excellent panetela, great value all

Sep 29, 2021

Excellent panetela, great value all around. I enjoy them at work. The taste is very satisfying, Cuban like.

Dennis F.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Good cigar but about 10%

May 05, 2021

Good cigar but about 10% are not smokable due to very poor rolling!

Steve F.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Perfect little cigars. Great for

Apr 17, 2021

Perfect little cigars. Great for a quick smoke. Love the flavor. Just need to keep them moist...shared some with friends

LISA W.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Over time since previous purchase, quality has FALLEN! ...

Jan 14, 2021

it has been years since I ordered ANY flavor of these [Victor Sinclair, D'Artagńan] panatela cigars... Oh BOY! THEY 've sunk to a low in quality, construction, packaging. More than 85-90% were wrapped/ rolled TOO TIGHTLY, impossible to pull on! I generally ALWAYS slit open at least one cigars upon receipt, it seems the filler is "o-Kay" ... just carelessly wrapped. Too bad. The protective plastic tubes NEED TO BE REPLACED! PLASTICS ARE SMOTHERING OUR PLANET! PLEASE! USE A PAPER BOARD/ REINFORCED TUBE to protect these once pretty good, NOW cheaply made cigars!? The circumference/ ring size *ALSO* USED TO BE "pretty good", again; cheaply made by *beginner* cigar rollers??? For the fluffed-up-descriptions, [THEY] need to re-train, re-form, re-hire from makers to representatives.

R.E. V.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Pretty good cigar, had them

Dec 27, 2020

Pretty good cigar, had them before, A bit expensive. I like size, Draws pretty good, Flavors good

curtis c.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Not what I was looking

Dec 22, 2020

Not what I was looking for.

Chuck H.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Too harsh to enjoy.

Dec 05, 2020

Too harsh to enjoy.

Stephen D.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Good cigar for when you

Oct 12, 2020

Good cigar for when you don't have a lot of time.

Randall W.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Won’t buy again

Sep 10, 2020

They were dry and brittle

Kimberly B.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

out of stock

Aug 18, 2020

You were out of stock of the assorted tubes. So, I purchased the ones you had. Nothing wrong with them but prefer the variety of the assortment.

Bruce J.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Great little Maduro cigar

Sep 09, 2019

Just the right size for me when relaxing,grilling or enjoying a drink.

A.J.

Was this helpful?

At Best, Adequate

Dec 20, 2018

Although An Exceptionable Value, Thompson Cigar Has Far, Far Better Products To Choose From.

Jeffrey

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

If the price was right, I would purchase again.

Dec 18, 2018

If you don't have time for a full cigar these will do. Nothing to write home about just average.

Terry R.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

very smooth cigar with mild aroma

Oct 26, 2018

mostly smoke on occasion and when on vacation

Farmer

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

I LOVE THESE CIGARS

Oct 01, 2018

GOOD ALL AROUND LITTLE CIGAR

Turk

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Nice small gauge cigar

Oct 01, 2018

This is a nice cigar for a fast smoke, small gauge but a nice length with great flavor

Jp

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

I would purchase this item again and again

Feb 06, 2018

Great smooth taste!

Cardee

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Long dried out backwoods without the flavor

Jul 20, 2017

Not really a cigar

John C.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Not worth the trouble

Mar 20, 2017

I have smoked several different types of small cigars like these and so I was looking forward to these. These will not stay lit for anything. It is a complete hastle to try and continue to smoke these for that reason. The cigar stays together and tastes reasonably well but the draw and the lighting issues make these worthless.

Mtaleisanz

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Not going to get these again.

Dec 15, 2016

Been smoking these for quite a while and the quality seems to be getting worse withe each shipment. Some are impossible to draw. Some have so many leaks that they can't be lit. At least 10 ~ 20% (4 ~ 8 sticks) per box are defective.

Rat 1.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Yes

Nov 17, 2016

Smoke every day

Me

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

makes good pipe tobacco

Jan 10, 2014

I unwrapped all 40 of them and tested in the draw. Out of those 40 I can only smoke 13. The rest are packed so tight they won't even draw. I'm not going to send them back I crushed them up and put them in my pipe. Pretty good pipe tobacco. I smoked two of those 13 and they taste pretty good. If you smoke a pipe I highly recommend it otherwise you can take your own chances. Great service from Thomson as always.

Phil

Was this helpful?

My Ideal Smoke

Mar 15, 2013

This is my ideal cigar, great taste and tasteful in all respects--makes you look great with a sleek, modern shape, it just embellishes "COOL"

Jm

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Great Little Cigar for the Money!

Jan 15, 2013

Good value for the money one of my everyday favorites

Robert D.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

not-for-me !!!

Sep 15, 2012

Used to temorarily substitute for another product.

Doc L.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

great everyday cigar

Aug 30, 2012

i am a big lover of Victor Sinclair cigars - this whole line of cigars are wonderful - i like these small cigars for everyday, but his larger cigars are great for those special occasions

Wickerwiz

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Overall very satisfactory

Jun 15, 2012

I like these and their size is just about right for me. Churchills are too much for me and take too long to finish. The D'Artagnans are light and have good flavor and do not trash my mouth hours later. Some of them have a harder draw but most are fine. The tube they come in is handy for the golf bag or for taking along to social events.

Chester

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

This is my NEW favorite everyday cigar

May 21, 2012

i have tryed all three flavors of this cigar and I'm still a maduro man these cigars have great taste with no after taste the wife even enjoys the aroma

Wickerwiz

Was this helpful?

I Would buy this product again

Jan 17, 2012

smoke two/three a day

Ed

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

good cigars, taste too harsh for me tho.

Oct 18, 2011

I like the cigar, but I like the Connecticut more.

R.E. V.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

good maduro taste and a light draw

Oct 14, 2011

enjoy the taste and easy draw

Quiff

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

I really enjoy these!

Aug 15, 2011

If you enjoy a good panetela, you'll like these. Good cigars, easy to light & good draw, even burn.

R.E. V.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

You won't be disappointed

Apr 15, 2011

This is a good cigar when you have a half hour to relax and enjoy.

Anthony M.

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Not Sweet enough

Mar 15, 2011

I Prefer the Cuban Corona Maduro, Would appreciate seeing them again

Dave

verified buyer

Was this helpful?

Victor Sinclair D'artagnan Panetela Maduro Tube

Victor Sinclair D'artagnan Panetela Maduro Tube

Description & Details

Customer Reviews