Free Standard Shipping on orders $125+  
MSRP $245.25
$183.99
| save $61.26
In Stock
Box of 25
The Romeo y Julieta 1875 Reserve Churchill Sumatra cigar delivers a medium-bodied smoke that features select Dominican tobaccos. Romeo and Julieta 1875 Reserve cigars are crafted with care and showcase a smooth range of flavors that come from using quality blends of filler and binder from the Dominican Republic. This premium Churchill also features a fantastic Shade Grown Indonesian wrapper that gives the smoke a slightly spicy hint of zest. Enjoy these excellent, medium-bodied, seven inch, 50 ring gauge smokes as a long, after lunch Churchill experience, or as a fine afternoon cigar. Romeo and Julieta cigars are premium smokes fit to hold a place of honor in any humidor and this excellent Indonesian wrapped Dominican lives up to the expectations of this brand with flying colors.
Profile
Medium
Wrapper
Indonesian
Shape
Churchill
Length
7 Inches
Gauge
50
Country
Dominican Republic Dominican Republic
Hand Made
False
Flavor
Non Flavored
Filler
Dominican
Binder
Dominican
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Sweet
False
overall rating 3.97 out of 5 Based on 117 Ratings
Customer Reviews of "Romeo y Julieta 1875 Reserve Churchill Sumatra"
5 out of 5
5 Star
61
4 out of 5
4 Star
24
3 out of 5
3 Star
10
2 out of 5
2 Star
11
1 out of 5
1 Star
11
Showing  1-50 of 117 Reviews
5 out of 5
The best in every category
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
Dry
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
My only problem was I wasn't able to place the order through the online portal. It simply would not accept my credit card so I had to call and be placed on hold.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Nice draw, even burn
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Thompson has never let me down. Good job
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
2 out of 5
They are dried out & most of the box is exploding on me I'm very disappointed in the quality of this box
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Classic, purchased often.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Good
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I've been a mail order customer of Thompsons for over ten years and I appreciate their service and responsiveness when I need o make changes to my delivery schedule. Oh, by the way, the cigars are consistently excellent.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
The cigars as shipped after I first opened had wrappers that continually unwound as I smoked them Quite disappointed RL Richmond
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Was a gift to a friend. Very pleased.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I think Romeo y Julieta 1875 Reserve Churchill is one of the best values for the money. A great smoke...
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
My order showed up 4 days after I ordered it. Humidity level was perfect. Very happy.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
Bought a box… Usually buy Ashton’s…’ And AVO XO… Just saying… When I had a good one… Good flavor. Only happened 1 out of 5!(and that’s being generous). This cigar is lacking.. Tight draw… Won’t stay lit… Won’t do it again!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Draw was fine, burn was a little uneven at times but there was a misty drizzle so hopefully they will do better on a normal day. Pretty good smoke, taste and aroma wise.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Good cigar thanks.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Mild, easy draw! Love it!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Good smoke. Good flavor. Always enjoyed.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
You just can’t find a better smooth, enjoyable smoke after dinner.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
2 out of 5
Having a lot of issues keeping them lit
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I've been enjoying these cigars for about twenty years I like the size and the flavor
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
Horrible dry could not even light them. Terrible draw
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
LOVE THE BRAND BUT THESE STICKS ARE HORRIBLE. TERRIBLE DRAW. DIFFICULT TO KEEP LIT.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great smoke good price
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
Some of the cigar's would not smoke well, the air flow through them were closed and had to puff really hard. Also on some of the cigar's halfway through they would unravel.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
What a great cigar, Perfect draw, flavor, just an all around great smoke. I like to switch around and try different brands but I have to get another box of these.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
All is good
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Good, not great, cigar.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
The worst box of cigars I’ve ever had. They were so dry the wrapper entirely flew off. After that I tried hydrating them with not much success. I took all of them out of the cellophane to expose them to the 70% humidity in my humidor. I’ve had to roll them in a damp paper towel for several minutes to keep the wrapper from flying off. The filler was packed so tightly I had to use an eighth drill to drill holes from both ends to get any draw. Even with all of that I have to continuously puff to keep them lit. I can’t put them down without having to puff like mad or relighting them. When they are lit the smoke is very thin. I’ll never buy any of Romeo et Julieta again. In fact I would appreciate some sort of refund so I can throw these out and buy some Padrons. Bruce J Becker
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
2 out of 5
Burn and draw have been disappointing.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Great cigar for the price..starts and ends with the same smooth taste.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Very nice 👍
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Good burn. Mild
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
These have been my favorites for over 25 years.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I have been smoking this cigar and the Robusto size for many years. They are my favorite go to cigars.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
The cigars are dried out and and are a very hard draw. I’ve ordered Romeo y Julieta Churchill’s before that were much better. These are disappointing.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
As expected
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
Too much uneven burn. Absolute waste of money.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Romeo and Julietta is a good cigar. I was disappointed that the Arturo Fuentes cigars were not available at all. Very disappointing.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
2 out of 5
purchased cigars nov. 20th to date cigars have not been delivefred,today is12/01/2020.Ralph Preta
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Excellent EC-very day cigar
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes2
No0
1 out of 5
Knotty and stale
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes2
No0
4 out of 5
Never disappointed.Good smooth smoke.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No1
5 out of 5
A real cigar pleasure. Wonderful mild flavor,fresh box, and no problem getting a full draw.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Great
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
They draw to hard
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
3 out of 5
The first cigar my husband tried to smoke was next to impossible. He could not get it to stay lit. Got disgusted with it and threw it away. Got a headache trying to light it. Not a problem with the next two...hope there will be no more problems!!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great flavor. Good smoke, some are hard to draw, but most draw very well.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
better price then all the other cigar online websites
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Usually good. Sometimes the wrapper comes off.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
My favorite cigar.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Excellent draw and flavor
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
2 out of 5
Does not burn well...too much work
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
It’s my favorite cigar! It’s that simple! 😂
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
2 out of 5
Good tasting stick but horrible burn and flaking, peeling rapper. Constantly had to relight. I would not buy them again... unfortunately I bought a whole box
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Draws well, smooth smoking and good flavor.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
3 out of 5
Generally a nice, mild smoky. Unfortunately I get a few that just won't stay lit, won't draw, that I give up on half way through. Not often, but too often.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes3
No0
1 out of 5
Not happy with these cigars , not sure if it’s this batch . They are wrapped very tight and have pieces of tobacco inside that’s like wood chip and not smokable with dry wrapping that cracks before you light and a struggle to draw !
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
4 out of 5
Some hard knots
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
2 out of 5
Cigars are too tight to smoke and burning taste appears about half way through. Had these before and were great. I guess a bad batch??
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
2 out of 5
Bad burning cigar have had several I had to throw away.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Great tasting stick, lots of floral notes with smooth smoke, i would give the burn a 8 out of 10...only had one from my box so far.....great deal.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes2
No0
2 out of 5
An ok smoke. I think the box was old or stale. That is why the cigar/ box was on sale.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Of the first five cigars I smoked three were fabulous one was good and one was terrible don’t quite understand it but that’s what it was
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I’ve been smoking these for over ten years. I find them a very pleasant smoke and not too strong.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
unwrapps when smoking
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great cigar for anytime. Smooth with a great draw and flavor.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
2 out of 5
Purchased for a friend. He didn't like.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
3 out of 5
Some of them do not burn right what out of five
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
I have not received the cigars yet. When did you ship them?
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Mild
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Good smoke when me and my Sons get together for a smoke.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I enjoy a good cigar at the end of the day.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Find these cigars to be flavorful, draw easy and satisfying. A good afternoon of relaxing with my cigar.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Just an awesome cigar, everyday or as a gift. This cigar is a great smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
This is a great Cigar for relaxing after a hard day working
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Better than the Macanudo Reserve Especiale or the Lord Nelson. Consistent draw and even burn from beginning to the last half inch.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This is my go to cigar. Great for every day or special times with friends. Awesome gift as well.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great for everyday use or special events. Wonderful while fishing and having some drinks with friends
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This is the best priced smoke ever.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
2 out of 5
Had to send back for refund. Usually good smoking cigar.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Great smoke, Can never go wrong with Romeo Y Julieta. Great for the everyday smoker.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great cigar for everyday use or special times I love Thai brand
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Very reliable cigar. Smooth
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
i have other cigars in my humidor, no problems
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
While the draw and flavor are good, there is a serious problem with the construction/packaging. On the day I received them, I noticed a small humidity packed in the box. I placed them in my humidor. That evening I took one out to smoke. Everything was ok for the first few mins. then the cigar started splitting down the side! I continued smoking it, and the flavor a draw were OK, but I had never seen this before. I suspect a humidity problem caused a swelling and splitting once the cigar was out of the wrapper. I don't know if this was caused by the humidity packed, or improper storage at the Thompson warehouse. I was hoping once the cigars became acclimated to my humidor this would go away, but while the problem isn't as bad as when I first received them, I am still getting the exploding effect.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Romeo y Julietta are my go to cigar. But I enjoy trying many other types of cigars Thompson's is able to provide that variety at competitive prices. Frequent discounts is a huge plus in saving a couple of bucks.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Good
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Great fishing cigar , everyday cigar or as a fine cigar with drinks
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Hardly ever get a bad cigar, these are the cigars I get every month
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
CIGAR LAST A LONG TIME AND BURNS EVENLY. NOT A STRONG TASTE.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great with an after dinner glass of wine, relaxing on the verandas.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great cigar for relaxing and reflecting
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
My hubby loves his cigars, and these are his favorite's!!!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Like I said before just a great smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Love
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Every day in my pool truck
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Every day
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Great smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Outer wrapper peeled off the day I got cigars.Bad outer construction
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
One of my favorite Romeo y Julieta blends of all time.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I enjoyed everyone of RJ's after every golf game or a special occasion with a glass of Porto or beer & some pupu's! I like mild cigars and RJ's was definitely a good purchase!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
1 out of 5
Did not taste good and one side did not burn Had a funny after taste Worse cigar I have ever smoked in 40 years plus of smoking I can't even give these away
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great sticks! I smoke these daily to end the day or when hanging out with friend enjoying whiskey or beer. They burn great and smell even better! Need to add them to my autoship queue.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Good price
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Romeo y Julietas are always a good choice. These Churchills are one of my favorite cigars!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great flavor,strong but not over powering. I can smoke everyday and enjoy a consistant flavor from start to finish.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Excellent smoke with a nice scotch
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
great smoke but the taste is a little bitter and acidic at times.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Mainly used when I am golfing or reading. I golf alot and read alot.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Great taste, Long pasting!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
I purchased this as a gift for Battle Buddy who still in Iraq, this is favorst cigar. I tried one, and wild, I 'm hook. ONE great cigar.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
Nice smoke with a Corona or glass of sauvignon blanc
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
i smoke while travelling for business.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
I enjoyed this cigar, and about 40 more, it lit well, burned great and had a very nice flavor. I have given these to my friends and recommended them to many others. I will continue to smoke the ROMEO & JULIETA 1875 Churchill Sumatra all Winter and Spring and expect them to be as satisfying as they were in the Summer and Fall.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
great golf cigar
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0

Question & Answer…

Something on your mind? Get a little more 411, pal. Ask a product specific question about Romeo y Julieta 1875 Reserve Churchill Sumatra.

Top