Ok not great acceptable

This cigar lasted me a full 2 hours, it’s a strong flavored cigar, good with bourbon as it make cigar taste milder. Very consistent construction, smoke is full of flavor. Very easy to start with a match.

As promised

Really good smoke. Easy draw and consistant burn. Rocky Patel continues to produce great cigars.

Not bad, but certainly not great.

Nothing beats a good cigar and Rocky Patel is excellent

Bien hecho

Find your profile as RP makes only quality product.

Good smoke.

Excellent flavor, great with nice bourbon!

Great cigar. Good construction. A bunch of flavor. Will buy again.

Just OK

Very good cigar for a mid-range smoke. Good burn, good flavor even though it is a little light.

Decent. Not a fan of box press though

One of my favorite cigars.

Mellow, nice draw.

The cigars are usually perfect, but this time they were too wet when they arrived and didn’t burn well. Anything you can do to help would be great , thanks !

Excelente

Great cigar, but they’re best after sitting in the humidor for a few weeks. I always light up a new cigar the night I receive them. Some are great from the start, but others like this one need to sit in the humidifier for a time. This one was too peppery for me when I first got them, but after 2-3 weeks of sitting in my humidor they are much better for my tastes. The peppery flavor has significantly diminished to where now it’s a very smooth and delicious cigar!

I like this cigar.

Great cigar. RP never disappoints.

My favorite cigar. Excellent construction, perfect draw and burn. Wonderful medium to full smoke.

These used to be my fav behind the Padron 1964...

Great Smoke

These are great cigars!

Wonderful smoke. Great service from Thompson. Thank you.

It has a nice burn and stays lit for a long time. It’s an easy draw with not too much smoke.

Good a bit small of a ring size

A wonderfull long lasting cigar. All five cigars arrived with no issues.

Even burn, great tasting

Classic broadleaf flavor. Well rolled evident by smooth easy draw

Good

to harsh hard to keep lit

My favorite go to smoke. All around good cigar

This is a very good cigar with a smooth even burn and outstanding flavor.

👍🥃

Smooth smoke and a good deal.

I wasn’t overly impressed by this cigar. It arrived just fine but the quality wasn’t what I expected from a cigar that received a 93 rating. It was smooth at the beginning but towards the end had a harsher finish. As for the burn, it was uneven and didn’t meet my expectations. I didn’t buy a box but bought the 5 pack which was shipped and received in good condition.

Hard to pull. I used 3 different cutters. I will NOT be buying again.

Awesome! Great burn! Nice taste.

Rocky Patel is consistently excellent, with the Vintage 1990 and Autumn Collection being two of my favorites. Very glad they're still offered here!

Draw good. Burned nice.

My all time favorite! Great smoke full of flavor. Many comments on its fine aroma! A high quality cigar!

Tasty, smooth smoke.

Yummy, good flavor, even burn

An OK smoke

Enjoyable & good evening smoke

I get these in the five pack fever sometimes, hard draw (pressure) too many times, quality if ok, smoke is light, a little disappointing since it's Rocky Patel, I expect more for the price.

Same comment on the platinum

One of my brothers favorites. 👍

Good change-up smoke. Pleasing flavor.even draw.

The quality was inconsistent, of the 5 cigars 2 didn't burn evenly.

Bought these for special event. People loved them. Smoked evenly, great flavor. Nice smooth draw.

It takes a week or more to receive the product. It is too long Amazon delivers with three days

Ok

The Victor Sinclair box I received were very poor quality. This is the 2nd time I was disappointed with this shipment. I will not be ordering from your company in the future.

Draw is too tight.

Good taste as usual, but poor quality rolling. Lots of twigs.

Average at best.

They were a hard draw

,

Another great smoke from Rocky. If you enjoy a pronounced Maduro flavor you will not be disappointed.

All have good smoke

Excellent cigar, smooth draw and even burn

Very good and very smooth smoke

now i know i don't like box pressed

Easy draw, good flavor

These are one of my favorites. Construction, draw and burn are great. The flavor is one of my favorite tastes. Have bought these many times and will continue to

Always a top of the line cigar. Let it spend a min of 7 days in the humidor or you won't get the best this cigar has to offer. For the price it cant be beat.

Good draw, although a few burned uneven

Five out of ten did not burn well at all I expected a lot better, wrapper pealed off and a hard draw

It's a Rocky Patel Classic! Great flavor and impeccable structure! It's my Favorite!

My absolute favorite cigar!

HIGHEST QUALITY EXCELLENT FLAVOR BURNS PERFECTLY

The vintage 1990 is one of Ricky Patel's best. Excellent flavor and taste with a nice even burn. This is a very good cigar especially when found on sale.

Another great Rocky

smooth, easy draw, even burn

Hard draw - flavor just so-so

Always a favorite.

Very, very nice cigar. Draw, aroma and smoke are great.

Good even draw

I was very pleased with these cigars. I usually have several brands of cigars, I found myself reaching for these cigars before the others.

Burned well start to finish. Packed with lots if flavor and rich smoke.

These RP's always have a spot in our humidors, great start and always are of good quality. Good smoke for the money with a good aroma, fast shipping...

Good smoke

strong full flavored. does stay lit.

This cigar has proved to be a long, flavorful smoke, starting mild for the color and increasing in complexity. One of my faves when I’ve got a couple hours to burn!

Really tight cigar. Used a poker and still was a hard draw. Goof flavor, but will not be purchasing these again.

You have to appreciate the Thompson 5 pack deals. However, when I purchased 4 of the 5 packs along with a box of Rocky Patel's and new humidor, all 4 of the 5 packs where just tossed in with the other stuff and all 4 packages ended up damaged. There were cigars in every one of the 5 packs that were damaged. This is the result of very poor packing.

My favorite cigar. Love the taste, size, and boxed press.

Good

This was a medium cigar. No problems with the burn or smoke. Last a long time

Good prefer round some were rolled so tight it was hard to draw

Great draw - excellent flavour - as we come to expect for RP

Great smoke. My new go to in the Rocky Patel stable.

Love them one of my favorites

Tough draw on the first one.. not impressed.. I’ll try another for final decision

One of the finest cigars I have smoked. The quality is over the top. A sublime flavor. Burns smooth and even. Good draw.

Love the rectangular shape.

Not bad, I prefer more flavor.

Due to a shipping error, this cigar was not included in my order.

Reliable

0k

Burn and flavor nice needs wprk onthe draw

Fresh and great 👍

Perfect just smooth!

Bought a 5pk and first two burned terribly with far too many touch ups required. Flavor was good. Let’s hope the other three are better.

Burn evenly but can be Canada dry at time & the leafs may on some.

Good draw

Good flavor and quality

Good Cigar 👍👍

USUALLY SMOKE CONNECTICUT, BUT PLEASANTLY SURPRISED WITH STICKS.

Another Rocky Patel favorite

Another favorite from Rocky Patel. Great medium smoke. Goes well with a dram of Whiskey.

Smooth smoke beginning to end on the rocky Patel. The aging room has a light smoke although a Nicaraguan cigar great start and very enjoyable to The end. Coffee clones are an ok cigar great aroma but gets bitter half way through. I do like to smoke with a coffee in the morning at daybreak or sunrise 🌅

I discovered this stick about 3 years ago and has been one of my favorites ever since.

RP has been a consistent choice over the past 10 years. These maduros have a mellow-moderate flavor, smooth burn and creamy smoke throughout the nearly hour-long session. My first time with the 1990 Vintage won't be my last.

The cigars I ordered all had a nice flavor to them with an easy draw. They were not rolled overly tight so it meant for an enjoyable smoke

Smoked these before. Just as good as I remember. Very fresh.

A good product. Draws well and stays lit. Would purchase again.

A nice flavored smoke. Burned uneven out of package. A little disappointing

.

Always one of my favorites. Mild,great flavor and easy draw. A nice every day smoke.

I like

Had to re light the 1990 half dozen times And a terrible draw. Awful.

Very difficult to keep lit.

AN ALL-TIME FAVORITE SMOKE!

Great

All very good

Wrapper falls off . Too dry even in humidor

Very hard to keep lit

Very good they have been my cigar for over 15 years

Nice smoke for the price

Smooth even burn with a nice easy draw. First time smoking Rovky Patel Vintage Madura and like the taste. No burning or biting taste smoking to the end. I enjoyed the pleasure of smoking this first time Cigar. It was fresh and not falling apart till the end.

good smoke

Smooth draw with even burn. Good flavor and excellent smoke!

I never received my order. Still waiting to get my money back

One of my favorites. Smooth and an easy smoke.

always a great smoke, never disappointed

Very nice

Still evaluating. Only have had a couple so far. Ok.

Easy draw; smoke is smooth; does not get hot or bitter at the end. Good value.

great service, quick processing and delivery!

All of the above, with flavor being #1!

Great smoke

Have to constantly relight it Flavor was just so so Probably will not buy again

Flavor was not 5 star.

terrible phone connection; website did not move to cart; billing was blocked by my Capital One due to poor signal; person was short tempered and rude. I ended conversation and worked thru the website. make clear that if customer wants the discount 5 pak customer needs to CHECK on the FIVE PAK section and not the item I am looking for another supplier

Great cigar, it has plenty of flavor and lasts a long time.

A favorite cigar . I can always count on a good smoke . Good draw & burn . Enjoyable on a relaxing evening .

Good

Must have cigars- I’ll be ordering more soon!

Unpleasant flavor, smooth burning with a clean draw

Strong good flavor

Great smoke

Great cigar. Good flavor and draw. One of my favorites.

The draw is difficult, the burn is uneven, the flavor okay if you can get any smoke. I will not buy these again.

Good cigars

The burn and taste great. I like the square press

My favorite smoke in a decent price range.

The cigar has good bold flavor, burns well and was a nice relaxing smoke while sipping whiskey.

Great selection

a nice start but a little harsh for my taste at the end

Not a good smoke. Too tightly rolled and tasted it the next morning.

Not such a good draw

Anything I've smoked from Rocky Patel has been good. And these Churchill sticks did not disappoint me either. They burn slow and smooth.

Thank you Thompson!

.

I usually order from the 5-pack fever arena, it's amazing to me that out of almost each 5 pack there is a least one and sometimes 2 sticks that are very loosely rolled, or have a rock hard space that will not burn well, making the smoking experience just a pain, no enjoyment. I see very little of this with Rocky Patel brands, surprised at the Drew Estates brands since they are usually more expensive. Seems lately that this is happening more and more, quality isn't matching the price. Hope it improves, it would be nice if you pay for 5 cigars, you actually get 5 you can smoke, and not 3 or 3 and a half.

Cigars have a nice flavour but many burn unevenly and won’t stay lit.

I found this cigar to be in the top of my personal selections. Try it you will like it

Nice smoke love dark cigars

Cigars are great - took forever to get the order though. Probably will not order from this company again.

As expected. Full bodied.

Don’t draw well Good flavor Hard to keep burning

Awesome flavor burns very nice one of my favorite

Long time favorite. Smooth and easy.

Decided to try something new with these. Very difficult to keep lit. They almost become a chore to smoke. They are OK for the price when they're on sale, I suppose, but there are others in the price range that are much better.