Excellent smoke!

Not "gourmet" smokes, but decent and mild. Very good deal for the money. And Thompson's always delivers quickly!

Love them, the service is great as well, thank you

Pretty good flavor, smoke well for a cheap cigar.

Won’t burn

They really are not bad. For the price I will buy again. Daily smokes on the run or work makes them a good choice to have a few with you and save your premium good cigars when you could relax and have the time to enjoy them. Also good to hand out to friends and family members that want to try a cigar. You won't feel bad if it goes to waste and not give out your good and expensive sticks.

You get what you pay for. 60¢ per stick.

Absolutely the very best sixty cent cigar you will ever smoke.

love the cuban mistake cigars will order again. Box also nice.

The cigars were a great deal but are rather strong tasting, pungent smell and very soft as if they were rolled tightly enough.

Horrible. No draw. You'll lose a lung trying to keep them lit.

Nice smoke for the price

Wish I purchased these sooner. Great cigar for the price. I will definitely purchase them again.

While the size of these cigars is slightly smaller than what I usually smoke the aroma and control make up for it. These are really great cigars for the price.

Great , would recommend them.

Few had hard draw and cracks in wrapper

For an inexpensive cigar it smokes well. Maybe a little harsh for some but works well for me.

Pretty decent cigars for the price.

Their OK, but nothing to brag about.

I'm a Punch guy so tough to live up to a great cigar. These smokes were a great deal. Not a great cigar by any means, but a great deal. Very loosely packed and not a ton of flavor but enough to make them worth it. Quick smoke and perfect for the golf course, which is what I bought them for. $.87 a stick, anyone who complains, is ridiculous. I wasn't expecting Punch but got 100 quick, easy smokes that I would recommend to anyone.

Good cigars with good price

Understand they are mistakes but I have found one yet that I could smoke the whole thing without it falling apart

Great quality. excellent flavor. Great price

The price is affordable. Good aroma. But I wish the length was about an inch longer....Panatella style. Overall rating: a good deal. Also, delivery was on time.

These are called mistakes for a reason and I’m good with that. There are some that can’t be smoked because of the mistakes but for the price I have no complaints because I knew there was a reason for the name of the cigar. In general they seem to be a good around the house cigar.

This is a great smoke for the price. It is tasty and for the most part smokes evenlly. Some canoeing and the wrapper has a tendency to unwrap during the smoke. All in all good cigar. will buy again.

Not bad for the price ,great for a afternoon smoke by the pool.

Very good cigar for the price. Not too strong. Will buy again

Good cigar, my golf go to... Most burn fine, good ash. Had a couple come apart, not a problem for price and satisfaction I get from these. put them in the humidor and they will come around. I will buy again.

The smell and smoke is mild really good glad i brought them.

One

Half of them were not smokable!!

Great light smoke I can’t tell where the mistakes are! Worth every penny.

Box was damaged by the time I received the Cuban mistakes. The cigars are very good! I would recommend them to anyone looking for a smooth cigar!

Great value

Nice easy smoke

All good

Great value

I have if you will look bought quite a few of this cigars! This last box was dried out to the point the wrap crumbled upon taking wrappers off. I’m going to order another box and than if there the same dried condition as May last box, I she endeavor to buy elsewhere. My two cents. Keith Luebke 6511 Batavia Avenue Wisconsin Rapids, Wi 54494 Cell 715,697,9797

Wonderful

The cigars were good. But I give only two starts, due that the customer service is not worthy it! I sent twice an email, never got an answer back! I will not buy anymore from you!

Overall, they are a good cigar for the money. I have found that some are wrapped so loosely that they don't draw properly.

Cigars are awesome

Not a mistake at all

This is a regular purchase for me. I usually find 2 or 3 that are loosely wrapped and pretty much unsmokable, but the price makes this a sure thing. Like the old Dr Pepper bottle used to say...10, 2, and 4; you can have these anytime.

Excellent quality for the price. Great flavor and burns well.

I'm not an expert but I think they are pretty good cigars for the price. I like them. Would buy again when I need more.

I received a box of cigars with a seal that was broken. The cigars are nice, but, I have the feeling I was sent a return from someone else.

Keep the deals coming…

Good

Very little flavor.

Nice cigar

A great smoke!

Best buy for the money. Only cigar I smoke. Burns good, and just a great smoke for less than a buck a stick.

Tight draw. Seems like a lot of work. Probably will not buy again.

loosely wrapped and falling apart as you get in the middle. cubs mistakes, bet description.

Very good light cigar for the price.

Been buying Cuban Mistakes for about 3 years now, they are very good for the price ,a great everyday cigar.

For the price point I really shouldn't complain cost wise but at the same time the cigars look nothing like the advertised pictures and the burn was terrible it would semi hold an ash but overall what killed it for me was the loose pack that left tobacco in my mouth no matter what cut I used and the smell was chemical like as was the after taste which immediately made me not even finish the 1st of the 100 I purchased I mean come on a few days after I attempted to smoke a cuban mistake I smoked a black and mild wood tip and it had less of a chemical taste to it which is kind of concerning considering the cuban mistake is supposed to be premium tobacco I will say though very accurate name because the cigars are a mistake and you would do a very big service to yourself by never buying these and instead buying factory smokes by drew estate or even factory throw outs by JC Newman for not much of a bump in price

Smooth smoke and good ash.

Was a nice mild cigar. I would buy them again

Both were fine.

Been ordering these for a long time. Very consistent and enjoyable.

Very good cigar at a very good price ! I will be Ordering them again.

Keeps going out🤲🏽

Too weak

Good every day smoker

They’re OK , not the best I’ve had. Thought they were gonna be bigger.

very poor won't stay lit and harsh

Most are somewhat nicely rolled. A few are loose. But, the cost was very good and had a nice draw. They are decent for the price.

Not good cigars for anything other than working in the garage or something. Poor construction and burn in most of them. A few good ones so far. Won’t buy again!

Enjoying them.

A good cigar but loosely rolled

These are pretty freaking good cigars. They stay lit, do not burn down the side, and the size is the right size for an after dinner or just sitting on the porch cigar smoke.

They weren't bad. I have had better.

Flavor good but cigars so dry. Must be 100years old to be that dry. Your qc department failed. Been a customer for 20 plus years in old days. Never have I been so disappointed. Probably will quit smoking again. If that's what I am going to get. Used to smoke Thompson custom 6 x42. Enjoyed them. But they where never dry crumble like these. Most likely won't order again.

Great flavor

Not a bad price for the size and quality of the cigar. It is a pleasant smoke.

very happy!!!

wound to tight, couldn't keep lit

They dont burn throug

As good as advertised.

Nice flavor great price

Only time I get to smoke these is in the U.S. 5to 7 times the price in Canada.Tax tax tax. Thanks again.

Good smoke for relaxing

This is a good/very good hand-wrapped cigar. I know they're called Cuban mistakes, but they don't seem like a mistake to me. The flavor and scent are pleasant, and the draw is good. Plus, they're inexpensive, so they've become my every-day cigar.

For me these are a great everyday smoke. Mild and not to hot.

Cost was reasonable, and burns evenly. Overall a decent purchase.

not what i wanted but they will do !!!!!

They are nice but a little dried out and loose. Crumble

Will never order from this place again. They tore the box apart and dumped 3/4 of the cigars in the box just to ship in a usps box. Missing 30 cigars and half were smashed. Whoever thought it was a good idea should be fired. Wooden cigar box is what they should have been packed in like normal. Never again

Very nice

a small amount are hard to draw, smell great very good quality for the price

Some cigars not rolled tight enough. Won’t burn Dense. Only tried two so far.

goof service

They are a good cigar for the price, they smoke good till you get towards the end some get a little harsh, they burn good, they stay lit, a good everyday smoke, I'll buy them again

Just ok. Great price

Great price for a lot of cigars. Better value than the "cheap" cigars at the gas station - still what I'd call "premium" cigars.

Great cigar to sit down and relax with

This is a very affordable everyday cigar for folks who smoke more than average in the golf course or puttering in the garden/yard.

Construction is terrible Taste is at a los Nothing good about them

Wraper could be tighter

Decent every day kinda smoke.

Good low cost cigars

Alright, 2nd half smokes better

The price was great, and the cigars are good and fresh,

Reasonable product for the price. I would purchase again.

Box is the way I like to buy.

The outside wrap comes off too easy. The size is a little bigger than I like.

This is the 2nd box I've purchased. I received tracking updates but not on the on this one therefore prompted the phone calls. However, I did receive them on time so thanx

Good daily smoke and a decent price. I'll buy something else to smoke on special occasions

Great Cigars

Entirely too loosely rolled. Taste is ok but they often do not burn evenly and though inexpensive I was expecting a tighter rolled smoke.

I like it. It is a smooth smoke and it burn good.

I never returned cigars before but I did these, Terrible taste, terrible wrapper

.

Been trying to return waiting on pick up tag

Just ok

Great for the price

The construction is extremely poor.They fall apart regularly. They were stained. I do not recommend them.They were a decent value though.

Good cigar with good draw and taste. A few have unraveled but still a great deal for golf course cigar. Don't cut end but just use a tee to make small hole in the end.

Ok smoke but some unwrap while smoking But for cost there ok

Not to bad a smoke. Some took a bit to keep lit, but hey they are discount smokes after all. Would buy again at that price point, but not much more !!

not bad for a every day smoke

They are loose and get soggy after just a few puffs. So, it's like a half cigar. Taste okay and at the price, I will keep and just not ever order these again.

Not a consistent smoke sometimes loose sometimes tight The good ones smoke nice

👎

They are labeled hand rolled but they are machine rolled with short pieces.

Great deal. Good smoke

They are okay, I have a daily cigar or two. Short smoke though I am used to Churchhills.

I used to love these cigars but these were loose and smoked bad. Never again.

I buy these for a everyday smoke, but more and more I'm finding myself picking on of these up over the more expensive cigars in the humidor. They my not burn even, but at this price; how cares.

Long time customer. Since TC sold, gone down hill. Last order was confirmed and track number received. After week I checked on order. Not a trace of it in my account. Called. Told Cubans out of stock by first girl. Second girl magically finds them, does a redo with a $30 increase. Tells me the $30 coupon I used is now expired and invalid. Some words were exchanged, she manipulated the order to reflect original price, tossed in 3 day delivery, and we were done. Cigars did arrive shortly there after. 2 agents in the Philippines good employees. Might have been my last TC order. Check my history, will be your loss, not mine. On a second issue, I have been charged a signature fee dozens of times. Never, never, never have I signed for a delivery. Do you have the web address for Cigars R US ? BEN in Commifornia. GO MAGA.

The end keeps falling apart

Very smooth draw with a very pleasant Aroma. The only draw back on this cigar is that the construction is very poor amd loose but for the price you can't go wrong. Makes a great, what I call, yard work cigar.

Generally easy smoking, but wrappers are thin and flimsy making defects frequent and causing drawing difficulty.

Cost was great, terrible taste, very loosely rolled

They aren’t a very tight roll

Great go to daily cigar. Easy draw at a reasonable price. Good quality product from a trusted company.

draw was tough, no flavor but cost you pay for what you get

I guess the really are "mistakes". They are not consistent and some are poorly packed. But. For the price, they aren't bad. I have bought more expensive cigars from Thompson that were not as good.

Good lil cigars not strong an very smooth thanks I would buy them again

The cigars are not made well and fall apart while smoking. The taste os just OK. I will not purchase them again

Very loose fillers they collapse as I smoke them and are bitter most of the way thru. Now I have to figure out what to do with the rest of them. Probably throw them in the trash. Definitely will not order again.

Can't review product ordered on 07/03/2022 this is 07/23/2022 still haven't received cigars

Good cigars

Very good good service good cigars thank you

not satisfied, poorly made

Good size/good taste/just right.

I thought read the description, but apparently I didn’t. I was expecting much more quality. The cigars don’t burn evenly, and I don’t like the draw. And, I don’t like the gage. Anyway…..

good everyday smoke

something a little different and way too cool

Wrapper has a bad taste and the cigar wrap is not tight and comes apart easily

They are ok, but smoke. Unevenly.

Some of them come unwrap when trying to smoke, a few of them had holes in them, other then that they were all right, but I would not buy again sorry

The filler is very loose. It reminds me of a cigarette. They tend to burn unevenly. Mistake is a good name for them.

Some of them have a chemical taste to them but overall they are a good smoke. Can't beat the price

Good cheap cigars.

these are not bad for the price, just don't expect too much

These are fantastic

You cannot best this cigar for the price! I've shred with some high-end cigar smokers and are agree. I was hesitant to write this in fear they will raise their prices as Mr. B's have.

ok

Not what I expected, No CAP on cigar. Mouth end To9 soft

good inexpensive product

My mistake. For thinking that a cigar for less than a dollar would be any good. Loose wrap, stems falling out, wrapper looks like wrinkled brown paper. Sent 99 of them back after throwing the first one away. First time I've ever sent anything back. Still haven't heard about a credit or refund??? It's been two weeks???

Great price, great taste, great packing, great deal. Will be back for great for me deal again. Thx (great) team.

Good economical smoke. Sure, some burn badly, but so do a lot of more expensive cigars. Enjoy the smooth flavor and quit complaining.

Strong but smooth.

Bad

Fairly good cigar

Great gave them out a A KofC golf outing and was a big hit will foot again

Great any day smoke cigar!!!!!!!!

About every fifth cigar can't smoke, wrapped to loose, other than that pretty good smoke

Found close to a dozen broken cigars. Also, this box had many cigars fall apart at the tip while smoking. I will not be buying these again, shame as they have been great in the past.

Not a bad cigar but it’s not a punch

After buying from Thompsons for nearly 30 years this is the first bad batch I've ever received. It seems like a good 25% are broken

They are a good smoke for the price. Having said that, they have to be humidified before smoking, and a number of them are rolled so loosely they just come apart.

Full bodied, well made, comfortable size, good price. Plan to order these smokes again.

Loose, burn incredibly uneven. Would like to return

Good

These I really enjoy. Even burn, can enjoy entire cigar. Many I’ve bought from Thompson lately are only good for about 2/3 of cigar. Then either break or won’t stay lit. Not so with these.

Flavor is mellow. The draw is excellent. This is by far the best low cost cigar that I have experienced in the last 20 years. And it smokes a lot better than many of the much more expensive cigars that I have tried. I will be using these cigars as one of the items to be included in a golfer goodie bag for a scramble tournament memorializing a good friend who loved his stogies. I think most of the golfers will enjoy them.

Great cigar as close to a Cuban as I've had

Well wrapped

Quality cigars great value.

These were surprisingly better than I had anticipated and they make for a good daily smoke. The cigars are very loosely wrapped (makes a good chewer on the golf course). They appear to be 100% tobacco and they burn well. The smell wasn't terrible (I didn't get any complaints from the lady). About the only thing negative is that the tobacco was slightly harsher that what I'm used too. I prefer a very mild Connecticut that can be occasionally inhaled. These had a slight bite that curtailed that desire. I would buy these again because at the price and volume of cigars I can easily smoke 4 or 5 a day and not feel like I'm going bankrupt.

Great cigars

good price for everyday smoke

Nice cigars for an everyday smoke. Even though each cigar comes wrapped in plastic expect about 10% to be damaged; tares in the cigar wrapper, loose or damaged ends. You get what you pay for.

Very mild, size of cigar I enjoy, overall very good

Good al round for the price.

won't buy them again

Just okay could be better. A lot of the cigars are poorly made some are broke and some have holes on the side of the cigar making then unusable.

Like the cigar and the price. Think it should have free postage. I have been a customer many years.

Great price but fragile cigars,they break easily.

Good for this price and great price to keep humidor full to maintain 70% level.

I have purchased these before, so no surprises here. Definitely not a well rated smoke, but for the price, this is hard to beat. Yes, some of them are rolled extremely loose and hard to smoke, but 80-90% are a solid daily smoke

I like smooth taste and burn for the price . Not a Rocky Patel but no where near the cost either.

Quality was great an the price was amazing an the timing the package arrived was also great…Thank u so much now I will enjoy😊

great product great value

the box was perfect and each cigar worth every cent the filling long cut with great binder

For the price , a decent enough cigar. Two will last 18 holes of golf

Uneven burn, loose packing

Decent cigar , have had several with wrappers that were so badly defective ,I could not smoke them ,or had to cut them in half to salvage part .

Muy buenos ,buen aroma y frescos

GOOD ECOMOMY SMOKE DRY. CRUMBLY. USUALY FALL APART BEFORE YOU GET DONE

I am trying to get the UPS label to return this box of horrible cigars. The UPS label never arrives, and I asked 10 days ago. It wasn't mailed to the email address I gave them nor the one on my file!! I've sent three emails. and talked to two agents. 1855281 is my confirmation number for the return. HELP HELP Joni Pastor- 20 year client, first time returning

Very loose wrapping. About 8 out of 100 was too bad to smoke but it’s okay for the price

Just got this order, have to bee able to smoke, so a review would be premature. Mike Holmes

Worst cigars I ever bought,unable to draw burns up on side lasts only ten or so minutes.crumbles and flakes.absolute junk

Good cigar for a good price

Good for the money

They are to soft and fall apart

Most of the cigars in the last order were terrible. Either the whole top leaves fell off or they fell apart on one side after lighting them.! I would say that only 1 out of 6 or 7 would be any good. If this new order of the same cigars turn out the same after trying one or two I am going to return them immediately and have to think about reordering any more cigars.

Great!

Good quality, burns slowly and well built cigar.

A great little cigar much better than I anticipated for being so cheap

This is a great tasting everyday cigar that I am sure I will buy again! I was very unsure about buying 100 cigars that I had never tried before. Friends, neighbors and golf buddies all agree this is a great value and very enjoyable smoke for the money.

Good smoke